What We Heard Report: Consultation on the Credit Risk Management Guideline

Introduction

Background

Sound credit risk management is essential to the safety and soundness of financial institutions. Weak governance or deficiencies in underwriting, monitoring, and portfolio management can expose institutions to significant losses and introduce risks to the broader Canadian financial system. Institutions engaged in lending activities therefore need effective practices and controls to identify, assess, and manage credit risk at both the portfolio and exposure levels.

To support these outcomes, OSFI is developing a comprehensive Credit Risk Management (CRM) Guideline.

The CRM Guideline will incorporate international best practices, address gaps in our existing guidance, and consolidate and clarify OSFI’s credit risk expectations. This modernization will also improve regulatory and supervisory efficiency and support timely responses to emerging risks.

Public consultation process

On January 29, 2026, OSFI published a consultation document on the proposed scope and approach for the CRM Guideline. The consultation closed on July 29, 2026. OSFI received 13 written submissions from financial institutions, industry associations, housing and real estate stakeholders, technology providers, and other interested parties.

Stakeholders broadly supported consolidating OSFI’s credit risk guidance. They also emphasized the importance of preserving established expectations, applying the guideline proportionately, providing sufficient clarity and implementation time, and continuing consultation as draft chapters are developed. This report summarizes the six principal themes raised across multiple submissions and OSFI’s response to each.

Stakeholders broadly supported consolidating credit risk guidance

Stakeholders supported OSFI’s objective of consolidating and modernizing its credit risk expectations in a comprehensive, principles-based CRM Guideline. They viewed the initiative as an opportunity to improve consistency and clarity while reducing duplication.

Stakeholders noted that Guideline B-20 (Residential mortgage underwriting practices and procedures) is well established and embedded in underwriting practices and supervisory processes. They cautioned that its consolidation should be carefully managed to preserve clear links to existing residential mortgage requirements and avoid unintended legal or operational consequences.

Stakeholders also asked OSFI to provide sufficient time for institutions to update their risk management practices and to continue engagement as draft chapters are released.

OSFI response

OSFI will consolidate and clarify its credit risk expectations to help institutions manage both established and emerging risks. The new guideline will present OSFI’s credit risk expectations more clearly and coherently.

To provide sufficient time for consultation and implementation planning, OSFI will publish the initial draft CRM chapters for comment in February 2027. These chapters will address the foundational principles of credit risk management and expectations related to residential real estate secured lending (RESL) and commercial real estate (CRE).

Guideline B-20 and its related guidance documents will remain in effect until the final CRM Guideline comes into force, expected in 2028. OSFI will clearly communicate any resulting changes, transitional arrangements, and implementation timelines before that occurs.

Stakeholders favoured a principles-based, outcomes-focused approach

Stakeholders emphasized that the guideline should remain principles-based and outcomes-focused so that institutions can adapt its expectations to different business models, portfolios, and risk profiles. They also asked OSFI to define key terms, provide illustrative examples, and explain supervisory expectations. Overall, the feedback called for a careful balance between flexibility and clarity in interpretation and implementation.

OSFI response

OSFI will retain principles-based, outcomes-focused expectations. The introductory chapter will establish foundational principles for sound credit risk management that apply across all business lines in which an institution is exposed to credit risk.

Where additional detail would support consistent implementation, OSFI will clarify key terms, concepts, and supervisory expectations and may use illustrative examples. The guideline will generally avoid prescribing implementation details and will instead allow institutions to exercise judgment in applying the expectations to their products, portfolios, and risk management frameworks.

Stakeholders emphasized proportionality

Stakeholders asked OSFI to embed proportionality throughout the guideline and reflect it in policy expectations and implementation timelines. Small and mid-sized institutions, foreign branches, and institutions with specialized business models requested that expectations be applied in a manner commensurate with the scale, complexity, and risk profile of their activities.

OSFI response

The guideline will be designed and applied proportionately. OSFI will consider relevant factors such as an institution’s size, business model, risk profile, and the nature, scale, and complexity of its lending activities. This proportionate approach will support competition while maintaining sound credit risk management standards. Credit risk management practices may therefore differ across institutions, but each institution will be expected to apply CRM Guideline principles commensurate with its risks.

Stakeholders supported separate guidance for wholesale credit activities

Stakeholders indicated that tailored guidance would be useful for certain wholesale credit activities, including commercial real estate and acquisition, development, and construction lending. They noted that these activities require distinct approaches because of their particular risk drivers, collateral characteristics, and sources of repayment.

Stakeholders encouraged OSFI to distinguish between more complex and lower-risk wholesale lending activities. They also cautioned against expectations that could unintentionally constrain prudent lending in specialized or regional markets.

OSFI response

OSFI will address CRE lending in a dedicated chapter of the guideline, building on its 2024 CRE Regulatory Notice. The chapter will retain a principles-based and proportionate approach that reflects the distinct risk characteristics of CRE lending.

OSFI will also address wholesale lending in a dedicated chapter of the guideline.

Stakeholders requested clear boundaries for counterparty credit risk and NBFI-related expectations

Stakeholders requested further consultation on incorporating international recommendations related to non-bank financial intermediation (NBFI) and counterparty credit risk.

They emphasized the need to distinguish expectations for counterparty exposures and exposures to NBFIs from those that apply to other lending activities, such as RESL and CRE. They cautioned that combining these expectations within the CRM Guideline could create overlap, uncertainty, and burden.

OSFI response

OSFI will develop a separate Counterparty Credit Risk (CCR) Management Guideline to reflect the distinct, market-driven nature of counterparty exposures. It will strengthen how regulated financial institutions identify, measure, monitor, control, govern and report their counterparty credit risk. The guideline will incorporate relevant standards and recommendations from the Financial Stability Board and the Basel Committee on Banking Supervision, including those related to exposures to NBFIs. OSFI will publish the draft CCR Management Guideline for consultation in February 2027.

Stakeholders requested greater clarity on RESL-related expectations

Stakeholders identified several RESL-related areas where clarification or modernization would be beneficial, including income verification, the treatment of vulnerable borrowers, renewals, and the interaction between RESL and other lending activities.

Stakeholders also asked for greater clarity on collateral risk management, including climate-related risks, fraud prevention, collateral verification, and ongoing monitoring. They noted that these issues are increasingly important as institutions use more technology-enabled valuation processes and third-party service providers.

In addition, stakeholders encouraged OSFI to recognize advances in credit risk assessment, including AI-assisted decision-making and the use of alternative data. They requested clearer governance expectations for model-driven approaches.

OSFI response

Guideline B-20 will be replaced by a dedicated RESL chapter in the CRM Guideline. The regulatory standards in the RESL chapter will remain equivalent with current Guideline B-20 standards. We intend to position the RESL chapter to be compatible with current funding structures that reference Guideline B-20.

The RESL chapter will provide greater clarity on borrower assessment, portfolio management, collateral valuation, and technology-enabled processes. OSFI will consider the specific issues raised through consultation and clarify its expectations where appropriate. The chapter will modernize the existing framework while preserving principles-based expectations for sound risk management.

OSFI recognizes that technology-enabled tools can improve risk assessment and operational efficiency and may support innovation and competition when they are governed effectively. Institutions will remain accountable for the design, use, validation, monitoring, and oversight of these tools and for risks arising from models, data, and third-party service providers. Their use must not weaken sound underwriting, collateral valuation, or credit risk management practices.

Next steps

OSFI will proceed in phases to support meaningful consultation and orderly implementation.

Consultation

  • In February 2027, OSFI will publish draft CRM chapters on Principles of Credit Risk Management, RESL, and CRE for consultation.
  • Also in February 2027, OSFI will separately publish the draft CCR Management Guideline for consultation.
  • Later in 2027, OSFI plans to consult on any additional CRM chapters, including guidance for corporate and other wholesale credit activities.

Finalization and implementation

OSFI expects the drafting and consultation to continue into early 2028, with the aim to finalize the consolidated CRM Guideline thereafter. Final timing and implementation periods will reflect consultation feedback and the scope of changes required.

OSFI will consult stakeholders and provide clear information on final requirements, transitional arrangements, and implementation timelines. Existing guidance, including Guideline B-20 and its related guidance documents, will remain in effect until the final CRM Guideline comes into force. Once the final CRM Guideline comes into force, existing guidance that it replaces will be rescinded.

Through this initiative, OSFI will remain focused on providing an effective, proportionate, and risk-based policy framework. This will support prudent credit risk management and the resilience of a financial system that powers innovation, growth, and competition for Canada.